
“If a man puts his hand out on the street, you have to put something in it.”
My Dad said that often. I think of him when I’m running around town with not a minute to lose and suddenly a person looms up, blocking my way, mumbling blessings and holding out a hand. All I want to do is brush them aside and keep going. Most times though, I swallow my impatience and dig through my purse for loose change. The beggar thanks me, but it’s Dad’s humanity and sense of justice that merit the thanks.
Foolish, sentimental, useless charity disturbs an American relative who comes to visit sometimes. When a beggar approaches her, she shudders elaborately and hurries away in disgust. She argues that the most effective way to give is through worthy organizations – that the State takes care of the poor… well, maybe. Well, maybe I’ve lived in Israel too long, but her attitude disturbs me.
I wonder what forces oblige people to beg in the streets and if they ever get used to exposing themselves like that. I wonder if they can survive on the coins people give them. My relative has forgotten the word tzedakah. Tzedakah does not mean “charity.” It means justice. Whether the beggar moves you to pity or offends your sense of smell, a few pennies fulfill your obligation and relieve a little of the misery in the world. And – this is my private feeling – I believe that the blessings of a poor man will echo again in Heaven someday.

I was in Jerusalem recently, hurrying to catch a bus. Something about this man sitting at the exit of the underground passage at the Central Bus Station drew me, and I stopped in front of him.

He was selling poetry. His own work, in English. His name is Robbie – Reuven Bramel, and he is an Englishman who’s lived here for many years. Once Reuven had a responsible teaching job and owned his home, he said, but a series of escalating disasters destroyed his health and brought him to selling his poems on the street. He explained his circumstances matter-of-factly. I felt a little guilty, as if he felt obliged to exchange his life’s story for my money. But there’s no self-pity in him, and his strong, cheerful spirit won’t be put down. Could I confront life and fight back like that? I don’t know, and hope I never have to find out.
Robbie handed me a patriotic poem (“My interpretation of HaTikvah”), which he then recited for me, rolling the r’s impressively. He also has a poem about the irises of Gilboa. Whatever I might think of his poetry, I respect him; he’s still battling, drawing on the poor resources he has left to earn a living. I told him I’d give his home address to anyone who wants to buy his poems (whatever you want to pay), so here it is: Reuven Bramel- Greenspan St. 10/25 – East Talpiot – Jerusalem.

Street musicians come from another place, and have different destinations. There are talented, professional musicians busking on our streets. They also have what to give in exchange for your coins – a lively klezmer tune, an aria from Carmen, Yiddish folk songs calculated to squeeze the heart a little.


All of us feel the effects of the worldwide recession. Here in Israel, we are also busy surviving a war. In these parlous times there are ever more calls on our willingness to give. But don’t pass the street people by. The coins you drop in their hands (or their hats) will weigh the scales in your favor, later on.






A lovely, human post.
When we were in Jerusalem last June, I kept wishing we had more coins with us. I should record that in my mind, when advising someone about touring in Jerusalem, bring some extra for giving.
Thanks for sharing their stories.
Years ago when I lived in Cambridge, MA, there were too many beggars there. Someone once asked, but if I give them money, won’t they just spend it on alcohol. (Too many of the beggars were drunks, not something I saw in Israel). The response was, so give them soap. Give them food. Give something. They ask because they are needy.
Maybe things are different in Israel than the u.s., but many of the beggars near where I live are drunk or high. If I give them money, they’re likely to go buy more alcohol or drugs. I feel that if I do that I am hurting them, not helping. Moreover, I don’t think they want constructive help or food. My husband once bought a homeless guy a sandwich and the guy threw it at him. And there have been studies that show that homeless people often make upwards of $20 per hour. Considering that I make closer to $10 an hour, I feel a little resentment that a drunk is asking for a handout when I have to work hard for much less money than he is making without providing anything useful to society.
What a beautiful and insightful post, echoing my very thoughts on tzedakah.
I keep coins in my purse for this reason, and also hand out dollar bills on occasion.
I have also bought fast food for those seeking…at least it’s a meal of sorts.
And, who are we to decide how the person should spend the money, it is not up for discussion, in my opinion, it is the mitzvah we perform that is what hat counts.
I was taught that as we have a mitzvah to give tsedakah, there must be someone needing it.
I sympathize, to a degree, with Fern – if a man claims to be collecting money for the townsfolk of Sderot and I know it’s a bogus claim, I won’t give because it angers me that he’s taking the name of war victims in vain. But I wonder if I’m right. Maybe he’s ashamed to say he needs the money – maybe he’s just manipulating people’s feelings – maybe my role is only to take out a shekel or two and just put it in his hand.
I’ll give something to a drunk, though. Drunks need to eat too. The $20 an hour sounds like an urban legend to me – how can anyone tell what a beggar makes? Especially if there are many people begging in a given place.
Mimi: Have you read The Dream, by Harry Bernstein…in his memoir he speaks of his grandfather, and the very issue of beggars. It is an incredible story.
http://jewwishes.wordpress.com/2008/05/09/jew-wishes-on-the-dream-by-harry-bernstein/
Without his grandfather’s begging, etc., his family…mother, siblings…and himself, would never have been able to emigrate from England to America…
It is an interesting and flip side to the coin, so to speak.
I agree with what you were taught…I was taught the same, and my children have been taught the same.
I’m really glad I found your website…
~~Lorri
Lorri,
I haven’t read “The Dream” but it sounds intriguing. I’ll look out for it. Who’s the publisher?
Thank you for the compliment…
Hi Mimi…Random House…here’s the link.
http://www.randomhouse.com/catalog/display.pperl/9780345503749.html
Thanks, Lorri.
very well written. here is a nice article about giving to beggars:
http://www.mitzvahheroesfund.org/mitzvah_heroes_educational.html
and then, click on the first article, the one by arthur kurzweil.
excellent stuff.
arnie draiman
http://www.draimanconsulting.com
The article is a bit over-explained, but still full of nuggets of wisdom. Thanks for the link.
[...] Israeli Kitchen: Pennies Towards Heaven [...]